Skip to content Skip to navigation

Testing for Common Values in Canadian Treasury Bill Auctions

Jul 2008
Working Paper
07-053
By  Ali Hortacsu, Jakub Kastl
We develop a test for common values in auctions in which some bidders possess information about rivals’ bids. Information about a rival’s bid causes a bidder to bid differently when she has a private value than when her value depends on rivals’ information. In a divisible good setting, such as treasury bill auctions, bidders with private values who obtain information about rivals’ bids use this information only to update their prior about the distribution of residual supply. In the model with a common value component, they also update their prior about the value of the good being auctioned. We use these differential updating effects to construct our test. The proposed test displays good performance in Monte Carlo studies. We then apply it to data from Canadian treasury bill market, where some bidders have to route their bids through dealers who also submit bids on their own. We cannot reject the null hypothesis of private values in our data for 3-months treasury bills, but we reject private values for 12-months treasury bills. Furthermore, we use the structural model to estimate the value of customer order flow to a dealer. We find that the extra information contained in customers’ bids leads on average to an increase in payoff equal to about 0.5 of a basis point, or 32% of the expected surplus of dealers from participating in these auctions.